Identify your partner's thesis statement. Copy and paste it
into the bottom of the Google Doc and then answer the following questions about
the thesis statement. Please be as clear and as detailed as possible:
•
Does the thesis statement answer the question
posed by the assignment?
•
Has the author taken a position others might
challenge or oppose?
•
Is the statement specific enough?
•
Does the statement pass the “so what?” test? Are
you telling your audience something they don’t already know?
•
Does the thesis pass the “how and why” test?
Once your partner finishes reviewing your thesis statement,
work together to revise both of your thesis statements. Once you have finished
revising both of your thesis statements, answer the following question about your
own draft. Type your answer at the bottom of the document.
We have noted several times that the thesis statement
provides a roadmap for the rest of your essay. Thus, revising your thesis
statement often entails revising the rest of your essay as well. Think about
the model Feeder 1.1 essay we looked at; how would the body of that author's
essay change in light of the revisions we made to his thesis statement? As you
revised your own thesis statement, did your roadmap change? If so, explain in 3
or 4 sentences how you will need to revise your essay in order to make it
consistent with your new thesis statement.